Packard, since she was one of my great-great-great grandmothers. I was particularly interested in the perspectives on E.W. As an introduction to the topic, Chesler cites writings of and by four women who were institutionalized as psychiatric patients: Sylvia Plath, Zelda Fitzgerald, Ellen West and Elizabeth Ware Packard. Issues in the myth of Demeter and Persephone are explored. Needless to say, her book sometimes comes off as quite cynical, despite her claim that 'I would like women to treat each other in good ways.' (Mar.)įorecast: It's prickly and contentious, but it's Chesler-so expect some buzz in the academic feminist circles she inhabits.The author explores perception of women and gender roles, making a case that 'madness' can be a normal response to intolerable pressures and exploitations experienced by women. Throughout girlhood and into adult life, women repeat the basic lesson-in Chesler's words, 'maternal envy teaches daughters to be passive, fearful, conformist, obedient-as well as similarly cruel to other women.' Thus, she says, 'an assertive woman manager might be viewed as bitchy and non-maternal.' This comment is certainly more digestible than, say, 'what complicates the aging process is a woman's life-long experience of all other women as rivals and potential replacements.' Chesler draws her evidence from interviews with an unspecified group of women with horror stories: backstabbing by feminist colleagues, sadistic gynecologists, battering lesbians, etc. Whether they acknowledge their mothers' viciousness, as Chesler does, or whether they're 'unconscious' and suffer 'amnesia' about the hurt, she says, the patterns are set.

From the 'demented Demeters' and 'murderous Electras' of Greek mythology to modern-day Mommie Dearest, Chesler warns, mothers and daughters are doomed. How could her own mother have been so mean to her? How could someone who 'borrowed' published ideas from her not acknowledge her or say 'thank you'? In this treatise on breaking the 'cycle of cruelty' between women, controversial feminist Chesler addresses why sisters fight, why some women prefer to work for men rather than for women, and other highly subjective cases of woman/woman cruelty. Chesler, author of the bestselling Woman and Madness, explores the 'shadow side' of sisterhood: women treating each other badly.

Women and madness phyllis